Claim-file review
Organize and evaluate estimates, photographs, reports, correspondence, timelines, and disputed scope components.
Technical claim consulting
Expert Witness & Claim Consulting
Structured property-claim analysis, estimating review, and litigation support for attorneys and insurance professionals.
Professional dispute services are administered separately from policyholder public-adjusting engagements. Conflicts are checked before an assignment is accepted.
Independent professional services
Technical analysis that is organized, supportable, and clear
Complex property disputes often require a careful comparison of estimates, photographs, inspections, reports, policy communications, and claim-handling records. A useful consultant identifies the disputed technical issues and explains them without overstating the available evidence.
David Messeri provides claim-file review, estimating analysis, appraisal consulting, and expert support subject to the requested role, qualifications required, conflict review, and a written engagement.
Scope of engagement
Focused support for complex property-loss disputes
Estimate comparison
Identify material differences in quantities, pricing, repair methodology, code items, and documented damage.
Written analysis
Develop clear schedules, demonstratives, or reports tailored to the assignment and supported by the reviewed materials.
Consultation and testimony
Support counsel in technical preparation and, when appropriate, provide deposition or trial testimony within the defined engagement.
A disciplined process
Clear administration from intake through completion
- Policyholder and insurance counsel
- Appraisal professionals
- Property owners and associations
- Construction and claim professionals
-
1
Assignment definition
Clarify the requested opinions, deliverables, deadlines, jurisdictions, and materials available for review.
-
2
Conflict and qualification review
Confirm independence, availability, relevant experience, and fit for the requested subject matter.
-
3
Analysis
Review the record, identify assumptions or missing information, and document the basis for conclusions.
-
4
Delivery and support
Provide the agreed work product and remain available for authorized follow-up, preparation, or testimony.
Discuss an assignment
Submit the matter for availability and conflict review.
Share the parties, property location, date of loss, claim number, requested role, and any scheduling requirements. No engagement exists until terms are confirmed in writing.
Discuss a Consulting Matter